Daniel E. Holloway
Email me about your case
Georgia case library

Emory Decatur complaint alleges meningitis and sepsis misdiagnosis before stroke

The complaint alleges that a patient presented to the Emory Decatur Hospital emergency department with altered mental status, vomiting, and lethargy, and that the attending physician incorrectly attributed the condition to COVID-19 and dehydration despite alleged signs of serious infection. The patient was discharged while unable to walk or urinate and without antibiotic therapy, collapsed hours later, and was diagnosed at another facility with bacterial meningitis, sepsis, and a stroke with permanent neurological deficits.

System
Emory Healthcare
Facility
Emory Decatur Hospital
Providers involved
Emory Decatur Hospital / James H. Elder, IV, M.D. / DeKalb Emergency Physicians Associates, LLC / Vituity-Georgia Hospitalists, PC / Vituity-Georgia Intensivists, PC
Pattern
Alleged failure to diagnose and treat bacterial meningitis and sepsis before discharge
Harm
Alleged stroke, sepsis, meningitis, right-sided weakness, and expressive aphasia

Overview

This page concerns a public complaint alleging that emergency providers at Emory Decatur Hospital failed to diagnose and treat bacterial meningitis and sepsis before discharging a patient who later suffered a stroke.

Chronology

The complaint alleges as follows:

  1. The patient arrived at the Emory Decatur Hospital emergency department on January 12, 2024 with altered mental status, vomiting, and lethargy.
  2. James H. Elder, IV, M.D. was assigned as the attending physician that afternoon.
  3. A chest x-ray was interpreted as showing likely right-sided pneumonia and lab results included an elevated white blood cell count, elevated neutrophil count, and elevated troponin.
  4. Dr. Elder diagnosed COVID-19 and dehydration and recommended discharge.
  5. The patient was discharged in a wheelchair despite continued lethargy, inability to walk, and inability to urinate.
  6. The patient collapsed at home early the next morning and was later diagnosed at Northside Hospital with meningitis, sepsis, and a left frontal stroke.

Alleged failures

The complaint alleges the following failures:

  • Dr. Elder prematurely anchored on COVID-19 and dehydration despite alleged indicators of bacterial infection or meningitis.
  • Dr. Elder failed to recognize sepsis despite the patient allegedly meeting clinical criteria.
  • Providers failed to order a lumbar puncture, blood cultures, COVID test, or MRI despite altered mental status in the setting of infection.
  • Providers failed to start antibiotic therapy before discharge.
  • The delay in treatment caused a preventable stroke and permanent brain injury.

Entities and tags

Emory Decatur HospitalJames H. Elder, IV, M.D.Bacterial meningitisSepsisStrokeAltered mental statusGroup A StreptococcusPneumoniaLumbar punctureBlood culturesDelayed or missed diagnosisPremature dischargeInfectionDelayed treatmentEmergency medicineInfectious diseaseNeurologyHospital medicine