Georgia case library

Exactech recall and bone-lesion case allegedly missed at The Emory Clinic

This complaint states as follows: The patient received an Exactech ankle implant in 2018, which was later subject to a recall notice in 2022. The recall warned that the implant could cause bone-destroying lesions. Despite being aware of the Exactech recall, between November 2022 and May 2023, Dr. Sameh Labib and Dr. Rohan Bhimani repeatedly failed to diagnose a growing cystic lesion beneath the patient's talus implant visible on multiple X-rays. The lesion doubled in size before being diagnosed in June 2024, requiring more extensive surgery.

System
The Emory Clinic
Facility
The Emory Clinic
Providers involved
The Emory Clinic / Dr. Sameh Labib / Dr. Rohan Bhimani
Pattern
Exactech ankle-implant recall followed by repeated failure to diagnose a growing cystic lesion visible on X-rays
Harm
More extensive surgery after the lesion doubled in size

Overview

This page concerns follow-up care after an Exactech ankle implant recall, where two physicians allegedly knew of the recall warning about bone-destroying lesions but still failed over multiple visits to diagnose a growing cystic lesion visible on X-rays beneath the talus implant.

Chronology

The complaint alleges as follows:

  1. The patient received an Exactech ankle implant in 2018.
  2. In 2022, the implant became subject to a recall notice warning that it could cause bone-destroying lesions.
  3. Between November 2022 and May 2023, Dr. Sameh Labib and Dr. Rohan Bhimani allegedly repeatedly failed to diagnose a growing cystic lesion visible on multiple X-rays beneath the patient’s talus implant.
  4. The lesion doubled in size before being diagnosed in June 2024, requiring more extensive surgery.

Alleged failures

The complaint alleges the following failures:

  • Dr. Sameh Labib and Dr. Rohan Bhimani allegedly failed to act on the Exactech recall warning about bone-destroying lesions.
  • Both physicians allegedly failed over multiple encounters to diagnose a growing cystic lesion visible on X-rays beneath the talus implant.
  • The delayed diagnosis allegedly allowed the lesion to double in size before surgery became more extensive.

Entities and tags

The Emory ClinicExactech ankle implantDr. Sameh LabibDr. Rohan BhimaniTalus implantX-raysRecall noticeDelayed or missed diagnosisCommunication or follow-up failureEquipment failureOrthopedicsPodiatryRadiology